Church Scene II

My favorite subject, St. Paul Lutheran Church. I've taken dozens of photos of this old church but never any good ones from this angle. The road tops a hill, and by the time I'd stop, I'd have the barn in between, or be too close otherwise... Today, thinking about this ahead of time, I stopped just at the top of the rise, pulling off the road into the grass, got out of the truck and crossed to the other side, and took these photos. Tell me which perspective YOU prefer, shot I ( [link] ) or shot II (this one).

I think this pair will be some of my favorites of the church, the rains of today had passed, but the sky to the east was still dark gray. Behind me, to the west, the sky was clearing and the late afternoon sun lit up the scene nicely.